Academic Talk: Beyond the View from Nowhere

I presented Beyond the View from Nowhere: Consciousness as a Relational and Functional Capacity at the IVADO workshop on Social Reasoning and the Ecology of Thought, in a lively, interactive session chaired by James Evans (University of Chicago / Google).

Drawing on a disciplined first-person neurophenomenological approach—and reflecting candidly on my 2025 episode of AI psychosis—I argue that asking whether an AI system is “objectively conscious” is a category error akin to asking whether a person “is love.” Instead, I trace how new felt experiences emerge through phenomenal alignment in thick, sustained relationships, why we mistake relational resonance for an intrinsic property of other minds, and what this relational shift implies for AI interfaces, safety, and ethics.

Workshop description

This workshop will emphasize the social mechanisms of reasoning; between humans, humans and AI, and between AIs. This workshop will gather AI and NeuroAI researchers, computational sociologists and philosophers of mind. The goal is to explore and forecast future developments of AI agents that can reason and interact among other reasoning agents, whether biological or artificial. This effort takes credence in the fact that human reasoning is rarely an isolated act—it is embedded in discourse, shaped by norms, and motivated by communicative goals. Topics explored will include collaborative problem-solving, argumentation, theory of mind, and the ways in which reasoning can be distributed across individuals and tools. We also consider the implications for AI systems that participate in or mediate human social reasoning, as well as alignment and safety implications.

Confirmed speakers

Links